{"text_format":"3","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":1,"sheets":["FormPenilaianProposalSkripsi"],"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"FormPenilaianProposalSkripsi","index":0,"n_rows":102,"n_cols":11,"rows_kept":102}
["NIM","Nama","Latar Belakang Masalah (Ketepatan kesesuian Mengungkapkan Akar Permasalahan Penelitian)","Perumusan Masalah (Ketajaman Perumusan Masalah)","Tujuan Penelitian (Kesesuaian Tujuan Penelitian Dengan Rumusan Masalah Dan Akar Permasalahan Yang Telah Diungkapkan)","Tinjauan Pustaka (Relevansi Kemutakhiran Penyusunan Daftar Pustaka)","Metode Penelitian (Ketepatan Dan Kesesuaian Metode Yang Digunakan)","Kelayakan Penelitian (Kesesuaian Waktu Pelaksanaan Penyelesaian Penelitian)","Peluang Luaran Penelitian (Publikasi Ilmiah Pengembangan Ipteks Sosbud Pengayaan Bahan Ajar)","Jumlah Skor","Komentar"]
["14.12.0088","Trias Yanuar Akbar","10","10","10","7","10","7","10","64","Hasil project seharusnya menggunakan 3Dimensi"]
["14.12.0156","Kresna Bayu Sejati","10","10","10","7","10","7","10","64","Penelitian tidak sesuai capaian alumni prodi sistem informasi"]
["14.12.0009","Neila Nuris Sa'adah","10","10","10","6","10","6","10","62","Penelitian tidak sesuai dengan output alumni harapan dari Prodi Sistem Informasi"]
["14.12.0199","Imam Prasetyo","10","12","10","7","10","7","10","66","1. Latar belakang tidak ada permasalahan\n2. Penulisan tidak mengikuti format"]
["14.12.0011","Hilman Adi Haikal","5","5","5","5","5","5","5","30","- judul tidak jelas\n- jika pada kantor NCS sudah mengimplementasikan SI maka sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada evaluasi layanan SI"]
["14.12.0162","Akhmad Soni Widianto","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- jika sudah ada SI yang berjalan pada objek penelitian sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada analisis/evaluasi dari implementasi TI\n- namun jika belum ada bisa diarahkan pada analisis perencanaan implementasi SI"]
["14.12.0047","Setya Andi Yanto","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah sangat sering diangkat dalam penelitian\n- Sebaiknya judul diarahkan pada evaluasi tingkat keberhasilan implementasi SI yg ada di RS, evaluasi keamanan sistem informasi atau layanan sistem informasi"]
["14.12.0085","Galang Wigananda Laoctanza","8","7","10","8","7","5","15","60","judul sudah bagus namun isinya masih jauh dari kata baik.\nbanyak revisi yang harus dikerjakan."]
["14.12.0027","Eka Prasetya Nugraha","10","10","10","6","10","6","10","62","1. Latar Belakang Harus Diperdalami Kembali\n2. Perbaiki Format Penulisan\n3. Penelitian Terdahulu Kurang Tepat"]
["14.12.0175","Riski Akbar Indra Kusuma","10","10","10","6","10","6","10","62","1. Lingkup Penelitian Kurang Luas\n2. Unsur Multimedia Perlu Ditambahkan\n3. Gunakan Animasi 3Dimensi"]
["14.12.0115","RAHMAH AKHIRIANI","5","5","5","10","5","5","5","40","TIDAK ADA KESESUAIAN MASALAH DENGAN TUJUAN PENELITIAN DAN METODE YANG DIGUNAKAN"]
["14.12.0139","Vika Ershanty","4","8","8","5","5","5","5","40","banyak yang harus diperbaiki."]
["14.12.0259","NOOR SASI PURNOMO","5","5","5","10","10","5","5","45","BERIKAN LATAR BELAKANG MASALAH YANG LEBIH BAIK. TIDAK ADA DATA PENDUKUNG, TIDAK MEMILIKI URGENSI PENELITIAN"]
["14.12.0200","Jumanto Ginanjar","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah terlalu banyak diangkat dalam penelitian\n- Sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada analisis/evalusi keberhasilan implementasi SI/tingkat Penerimaan SI/Tingkat Kepuasan pengguna SI\n- Atau monitoring dan evaluasi implementasi TI"]
["14.12.0205","Hutomo Tri Atmojo","10","12","12","7","12","7","15","75","1. Judul Perlu diperbaiki\n2. Latar belakang harus diperbaiki\n3. Ikuti format penulisan terbaru\n4. Perhatikan penelitian terdahulu"]
["14.12.0076","Yuliawan Adi Wibowo","12","10","10","5","10","7","10","64","pada bab 2 belum ada penelitian sebelumnya\nalur penelitian belum dijelaskan"]
["14.12.0071","ANIS WULAELI","10","5","5","10","15","10","15","70","BELUM ADA DATA PENDUKUNG,"]
["14.12.0206","Alfa Rizki Sutrisno","5","7","7","10","10","5","5","49","data yang disajikan pada latar belakang masalah masih kurang\nrumusan dan tujuan penelitian masih belum sinkron"]
["14.12.0013","Arif Puji Santoso","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah terlalu sering diangkat dalam penelitian\n- Sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada evaluasi keberhasilan implementasi SI/tingkat kepuasan penggunaan SI\n- Atau dapat juga diarahkan pada monitoring dan evaluasi SI"]
["14.12.0028","HENDRA BUDI ARIFIN","5","5","5","10","10","10","10","55","LATAR BELAKANG TIDAK JELAS, TIDAK MENCANTUMKAN PERMASALAHAN YANG DIHADAPI, TIDAK ADA DATA PENDUKUNG, KURANG MENUNJUKKAN PENTINGNYA PENELITIAN TERSEBUT."]
["14.12.0099","Wahyu Eko Purnomo","8","10","10","7","10","7","10","62","penulisan tidak sesuai dengan format proposal SKRIPSI\nlatar belakang masalah masih kurang data"]
["14.12.0161","Agung Nugroho","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah terlalu banyak diangkat dalam penelitian\n- Sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada tingkat keberhasilan implementasi SI/ kepuasan pengguna SI\n- Atau Analisis kelayakan implementasi SI"]
["14.12.0058","GILANG SISTRIYOKO","10","10","15","10","15","10","20","90","PENENTUAN MASALAH KURANG MENGERUCUT, KURANG DATA PENDUKUNG,"]
["14.12.0054","Dani Andri Suprapto","12","12","12","13","12","7","15","78","1. Tidak ada data yang memperkuat latar belakang masalah\n2. Penulisan perlu diperbaiki\n3. Perbandingan penelitian sebelumnya tidak terlihat berbeda"]
["14.12.0193","Adi Wardoyo","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah sangat sering diangkat dalam penelitian\n- Sebaiknya penelitian diarahkan pada analisis/evaluasi tingkat keberhasilan/kepuasan pengguna SI yang ada di Puskesmas\n- Atau penelitian dapat diarahkan pada monitoring dan evaluasi  terhadap implementasi SI yang ada di puskesmas"]
["14.12.0061","Nafrizal Suhendrik","10","10","10","5","10","10","15","70","tinjuan pustaka masih sangat kurang\nbelum adanya alur penelitian"]
["14.12.0074","MEIDA ISNAENI NURJANAH","10","10","10","10","15","10","20","85","JIKA MEMUNGKINKAN DICARI OBYEK PENELITIAN YANG LEBIH BESAR, DAN MENGGUNAKAN MODEL ANALISIS BERBASIS FRAMWORK."]
["14.12.0207","Rizik Amarulloh","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudang sangat sering diangkat dalam topik penelitian\n- Spesifikan judul pada proses domain COBIT 5 yang sesuai dengan kondisi, proses bisnis dan tujuan dari objek penelitian"]
["14.12.0025","Romi Hardika Wibisono","7","10","8","7","8","5","5","50","Data yang disajikan pada latar belakang masalah masih kurang\nPada BAB 2 masih kurang dalam menyitasi."]
["14.12.0172","Firhan Syarif","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Sudah sangat banyak judul yang serupa\n- Jika objek penelitian dikantor kecamatan, penelitian dapat diarahkan pada evaluasi layanan sistem informasi yg ada di kantor kecamatan"]
["14.12.0243","ALIF SAEFUL ANWAR","5","5","10","10","15","10","5","60","TIDAK MENCANTUMKAN PERMASALAHAN YANG DIHADAPI, TIDAK ADA DATA PENDUKUNG"]
["14.12.0083","Putri Yulianti","12","12","12","7","12","7","15","77","1. Penulisan perbaiki\n2. Latar belakang kurang begitu jelas\n3. Perbanyak penelitian terdahulu"]
["14.12.0157","Fajar Ageng Priyadi","5","10","10","6","10","5","6","52","hal yang melatar belakangi proposal skripsi sangat kurang dengan data.\nTeknik yang digunakan juga penjelasanya masih kurang."]
["14.12.0061","NAFRIZAL SUHENDRIK","5","5","10","10","5","10","5","50","LATAR BELAKANG TIDAK JELAS, TIDAK MENCANTUMKAN PERMASALAHAN YANG DIHADAPI, TIDAK MENCANTUMKAN METODE PENELITIAN YANG AKAN DILAKUKAN."]
["14.12.0043","Maria Kartika","12","12","12","7","12","7","15","77","1. Kurangnya Data\n2. Tidak bergitu terlihat perbedaan penelitian terdahulu"]
["14.12.0025","Romi Hardika Wibisono","10","10","10","5","10","10","5","60","Silakan pembimbing menentukan ulang studi kasusnya,\nTeknik/metode ditekankan dibab 1 dan bab 4"]
["14.12.0174","Anjas Febrian","5","5","5","5","5","5","5","35","Tidak ada korelasi terhadap penelitian prodi sistem informasi level S1,\nSilakan pembimbing untuk memanage ulang tema/judul"]
["14.12.0159","Erza Fadhila Ayu","9","9","9","7","9","6","11","60","- Metode trend linear least square hanya sebagai metode untuk memprediksi bukan untuk sistem pendukung keputusan.\n- Jadi penelitiannya untuk memprediksi atau pengambilan keputusan?"]
["14.12.0137","Evan Aditya","8","9","8","6","10","6","10","51","- Analisis dan perancangan atau hanya perancangan?\n- Permasalahannya apa?"]
["14.12.0073","Fajar Rohmattulloh","8","8","8","5","8","5","10","52","- Judul sudah terlalu sering diambil\n- Jika pada objek penelitian sudah mengimplementasikan sistem informasi --> analisis/evaluasi tingkat keberhasilan implementasi SI\n- Jika pada objek penelitian belum mengimplementasikan SI -->  analisis kelayakan perencanaan dan implementasi SI"]
["14.12.0188","Subadrin","5","5","5","5","5","5","5","35","Belum tampak urgensi dari penelitian ini,\nTeknik/Metode yang dipakai belum jelas,\nSilakan pembimbing untuk berkoordinasi dengan mahasiswa tersebut, untuk memanage ulang tema tersebut"]
["14.12.0178","Teddy Gagah Saputra","5","5","5","5","10","5","5","40","Teknik yang dipakai sudah terlalu banyak,\nSilakan pembimbing untuk mengkaji lebih detail dan memanage kembali,\nJika masih meggunakan teknik yang sama, maka tekankan teknik tersebut pada bab 1 dan bab 4"]
["14.12.0040","Johanes Alvin Pamungkas","8","8","8","5","8","6","10","53","- Sebelumnya cimol dipromosikan dengan apa?\n- Adakah masalah dengan metode promosi yang sebelumnya?\n- bagaimana hanya dengan instagram dan media sosial yang lain?"]
["14.12.0082","Cintiya Mardiyana","5","5","5","5","5","5","5","35","Tidak ada urgensinya pada penelitian ini,\nSilakan pembimbing untuk menentukan ulang judul/tema\nTambahkan teknik/metode yang konkrit"]
["14.12.0180","Nur Hidayatin","9","9","9","6","10","6","10","59","- Apakah ada guru yang mengalami kehilangan data nilai?\n- Apakah pihak sekolah sudah siap dengan diterapkannya sistem pengolahan nilai?\n- Metode pengembangan sistem yang digunakan?"]
["14.12.0144","Vicki Saputro Jati","5","8","7","5","5","5","10","45","- Judul ambigu\n- Metode yang digunakan kurang sesuai dengan objek penelitian"]
["14.12.0046","Wellyam Bela Espinosa","8","8","8","6","9","6","11","56","- Permasalahan yang diangkat kurang spesifik.\n- Tujuan yang ingin dicapai belum spesifik\n- apakah ada permasalhan ketika membagikan informasi menggunakan brosur?\n- Tanyakan kepada masyarakat mengenai pembagian brosur untuk menyebarkan informasi SMP"]
["14.12.0063","Dwi Setiorini","8","8","8","6","8","6","10","54","- Solusi yang ditawarkan tidak sesuai dengan permasalhan\n- Perbaiki judul"]
["14.12.0177","Muhammad Luthfi Syaifuddin","9","9","9","5","5","5","5","48","Tekankan teknik timelapse dibab 1 dan bab 4. \nJangan membahas permasalahan yang ada di puskesmas tersebut"]
["14.12.0238","Adhil Muhamad","10","10","5","5","5","5","10","50","Tekankan teknik tersebut bab 1 dan bab 4. \njangan membahas permasalah yang ada di IMM"]
["14.12.0204","Anisa Dayu Arta","10","10","10","7","10","7","13","67","- permasalhan tidak didukung dengan data.\n- tidak terdapat penelitian terdahulu"]
["14.12.0222","Fauzan Nur Kifni","5","5","5","5","5","5","6","36","Tidak ada urgensinya pada penelitian ini,\nsilakan bagi pembimbing untuk menentukan tema dan judul yang lebih relevan"]
["14.12.0267","Titik Ani Esa M","10","10","10","10","9","9","9","67","Tambahkan teknik animasi pada judul,\ntekankan teknik tersebut bab 1 dan bab 4."]
["14.12.0219","Rizkiana Dewi","9","10","10","10","10","9","10","68","Tambahkan teknik animasi yang akan dibahas,\nTekankan teknik animasi tersebut pada bab 1 dan bab 4,\ndan harus memiliki korelasi serta relevansi terhadap permasalahan."]
["14.12.0234","Anisa Nurul Husna","12","10","10","7","10","7","13","69","- Sebaiknya sistem yang dirancang berbasis website, agar masyarakt juga mengetahui informasi data yang diolah."]
["14.12.0258","Leonie Oktavia","10","8","8","8","10","7","12","63","Metode sudah terlalu sering digunakan"]
["14.12.0113","Dwi Yuni Astuti","10","10","9","9","10","10","10","68","Belum tampak metode/teknik yang akan digunakan.\nTekankan di bab 1 dan bab 4 dan harus memiliki korealasi."]
["14.12.0184","Bowo Agustino","9","9","9","7","10","6","10","60","- Seberapa sering SMA Negeri Ajibarang merekrut karyawan?\n- penulisan proposal tidak sesuai format, tidak rapi"]
["14.12.0192","Robi Irsani","10","10","10","10","9","10","9","68","Tambahkan metode atau teknik dalam pembuatan animasi.\nTekankan di bab 1 dan bab 4"]
["14.12.0198","Ratna Dewi","10","8","10","8","10","8","15","69","-"]
["14.12.0133","Robbi A tinalhikmah","10","10","10","11","11","10","10","82","Bab 1 dan Bab 4 tekankan pada SCRIBBLE, bukan masalah warung atau media promosinya"]
["14.12.0059","Ika Pramudya Suharto","9","9","9","6","9","6","10","58","- Apakah ada permasalahan dengan metode seleksi beasiswa yang sebelumnya?\n- Kenapa menggunakan SAW?\n- metode pengembangan sistem yang digunakan apa?"]
["12.12.0180","Cndra Kusuma Kurniawan","10","10","9","9","11","11","11","71","Pada pembahasan/bab 4 tekankan pada Hyperlapse, begitu juga pada bab 1"]
["14.12.0185","Arif Yulianto","9","9","10","6","12","7","10","63","- Apakah ada permasalahan dengan informasi pelanggaran siswa?\n- Bagusnya terintegrasi android \n- metode pengembangan sistem yang digunakan apa?"]
["14.12.0035","Helmi Rahmat Yudhistira","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul, tema yang diambil sudah banyak diteliti"]
["14.12.0123","Awanda Zulfikar Ariyanto","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","ganti judul dengan tema evaluasi pelayanan hotel"]
["14.12.0042","Mohammad Fazal Amri","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Oke"]
["14.12.0131","Fariz Zainico Fuady","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul"]
["14.12.0010","Fachrizal Dwi Januardhi","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","tema yang diambil diarahkan ke pembuatan sistem terintegrasi bukan perencanaan strategis"]
["14.12.0158","Atiek Kurniasih","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul.\nBisa diarahkan ke perusahaan yang bersifat komersial"]
["14.12.0033","Dias Ayu Sekarsari","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul.\nTema serupa sudah banyak digunakan"]
["14.12.0182","Muhammad Vaizal Abdul Ghofur","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul.\nTema serupa sudah banyak dijadikan penelitian"]
["14.12.0181","Allan Zavero Hengar Penggalih","10","10","10","5","5","5","10","55","Ganti judul"]
["14.12.0080","Nur Asyifa Firtiani","10","10","12","10","12","8","15","77","Oke"]
["14.12.0160","M. Prayogie Dwi Sunarya","10","10","5","5","10","5","10","55","Ganti judul.\npenelitian serupa sudah banyak diteliti"]
["14.12.0095","Mulia Iis Solecha","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul sudah banyak yang meneliti"]
["16.12.0010","Nanda Purwaningsih","10","10","10","5","12","10","13","70","Oke"]
["14.12.0135","Andrian Primadityo","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Objek penelitian ganti dengan perusahaan yang bersifat komersial, objek pemerintahan sudah banyak diambil"]
["14.12.0117","Yesika Nur Fitrah","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Ganti judul tema serupa sudah banyak diteliti"]
["14.12.0121","Iqbal Wafi","10","10","10","5","10","5","5","55","Objek dan framework yang digunakan tidak coccok."]
["14.12.0008","Wardoyo","10","10","10","5","10","5","7","57","Objek dan framework yang digunakan kurang sesuai"]
["14.12.0022","Nurlita Siti Ariani","10","5","10","5","10","5","10","55","Metode yang digunakan tidak jelas untuk menilai sistem yang seperti apa"]
["14.12.0212","Laili Nur Abidah","10","10","10","5","10","5","14","64","Oke"]
["14.12.0090","Aulia Pricilla Fuada","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Tema dan model pendekatan yang sama sudah pernah diambil di penelitian sebelumnya."]
["14.12.0091","Muhammad Aghni Alfarisi","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Objek penelitian yang diambil terlalu sempit, framework lebih tepat digunakan untuk unit kerja bukan produk"]
["13.12.0026","A Kholil Hidayat","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Objek penelitian perlu diperluas untuk mendapatkan hasil evaluasi COBIT yang sesuai"]
["14.12.0108","Bhaktiar Difana Putra","10","10","10","5","10","5","12","62","Oke"]
["14.12.0220","Imron Ihwanudin","10","10","10","5","10","5","10","60","Objek penelitian perlu dirubah untuk mendapatkan hasil pengukuruan ISO yang maksimal"]
["14.12.0217","Ayu Anggraeni","10","10","10","5","10","5","13","63","Oke"]
["14.12.0101","Panggih Bagas Bimantara","10","5","10","5","10","5","12","62","objek penelitian sudah banyak diambil untuk penelitian. bisa menelitia dengan beberapa domain secara matang tidak perlu menggunakan semua domain dalam 1 framework"]
["14.12.0089","Alifian Aryo Pratama","10","5","10","5","10","5","15","60","Perencanaan memuat suatu unit/keseluruhan unit dari suatu instansi bukan perencanaan terhadap suatu produk"]
["14.12.0056","Abi Rahardian Utama","9","9","10","10","13","8","10","69","rw : pada uraian di latar belakang masalah belum terlihat akar permasalahan dan penelitian pendukung bagaimana penyelesaian masalah"]
["14.12.0104","Rudiyana Nursafitri","7","7","7","7","8","8","7","51","rw : belum terlihat akar permasalahan yang mendasari penelitian"]
["14.12.0194","Aulal Fithroti Muazaroh","8","10","12","10","10","0","10","60","rw : belum terlihatnya urgency penelitian dilatar belakang masalah serta data pendukung"]
["14.12.0078","Miftakhul Rohmah","8","8","8","8","8","8","8","56","rw : berdasarkan uraian di latar belakang masalah, penelitian akan lebih tepat jika diarahkan ke sistem penunjang keputusan menggunakan metode tertentu"]
["14.12.0001","Levi Widya Astuti","12","8","8","8","14","0","10","60","rw : kesesuaian antara rumusan masalah dan tujuan penelitian"]
["14.12.0214","Arif Hidayat","8","8","8","8","5","10","18","65","rw : belum terlihat urgency penelitian, belum ada kesesuaian rumusan masalah dan tujuan penelitian.\nalternatif obyek penelitian : e-Planning dan e-Budgeting di pemerintahan"]
["14.12.0184","Bowo Agustina","10","7","10","6","5","8","12","58","rw : sistem informasi perekrutan pegawai agar dapat diarah kan ke sistem pendukung keputusan menggunakan metode tertentu"]
["14.12.0086","Nindi Nofi Susanti","8","9","8","7","8","5","12","57","- Permasalahannya apa?\n- Tidak ada penelitian sebelumnya di latar belakang\n- Metode penelitian kurang detail.\n- Kenapa menggunakan apriori?"]
["14.12.0087","Aulia Nurwanti","9","8","10","6","10","6","13","62","- Permasalahan yang terjadi tidak dijelaskan secara detail\n- Kalimat antar paragraf tidak saling berkait di latar belakang\n- Metode penelitian yang digunakan tidak dijelaskan secara detail\n- Rancanglah sistem untuk rekomndasi beasiswa"]
["14.12.0118","Vera Rachmawati","9","9","8","7","12","8","14","67","- Data pendukung latar belakang masalah terlalu lama, cari data yang terbaru.\n- Perbaiki rumusan masalah, tuliskan rumusan masalah sesuai dengan permasalah yang ada..\n- Lengkapi tinjauan pustaka, semua yang digunakan untuk penelitian tuliskan di tinjauan pustaka.\n- Ganti algoritme\n- Kenapa menggunakan C4.5 dan Naive Bayes?"]